Name Song Percentage Tie Breaker Zack Exempt Justin (Supersong) Exempt Ryan H. Exempt Aaron H. Exempt Justin H. Exempt Pace Strictly Business 89.1% James C. Trip Machine Jungle 88.0% Joshua M. Strictly Business 87.5% Nick E. Strictly Business 87.0% Tony S. Strictly Business 85.4% Tim N. Strictly Business 83.3% Matt H. Strictly Business 82.3% Carlos C. Strictly Business 81.8% Dave N. Trip Machine Jungle 78.8% YoshiXL Strictly Business 78.1% Shin K. Strictly Business 77.1% Geno B. Strictly Business 76.6% Jim M. Trip Machine Jungle 76.0% James G. Strictly Business 73.4% Cody B. Paranoia Dirty Mix 73.1% Ben G. Trip Machine Jungle 72.8% 197 Freddy C. Paranoia Dirty Mix 72.8% 196 Josh H. Strictly Business 71.4% 167 William J. Strictly Business 71.4% 164 Philp R. Trip Machine Jungle 69.6% James H. Strictly Business 68.8% Marc A. Paranoia Dirty Mix 65.7% Jennifer K. Strictly Business 64.6% Brad K. Strictly Business 63.5% Michael I. Strictly Business 59.4% Vinny Strictly Business 59.4% 149 Richard N. Strictly Business 55.2% 99 James G. Strictly Business 52.6% Bonnie R. Strictly Business 52.1% Ray K. Paranoia Dirty Mix 50.7% Amber R. Trip Machine Jungle 43.8% Paul N. Trip Machine Jungle 40.6% Josh V. Paranoia Dirty Mix 36.6% Evelgn T. Strictly Business 22.9% Qualifying Songs: Strictly Business (Maniac), SP-Trip Machine Jungle Mix (Trick), Paranoia Dirty Mix (Basic). Tie Breaker: I Believe in Miracles (Maniac)